Exilian

Game Design and Project Resources: The Workshops Quarter => Computer Game Development - The Indie Alley => Bigosaur => Topic started by: Jubal on May 26, 2018, 07:39:37 PM

Title: Jubal's Ideas for SoaW
Post by: Jubal on May 26, 2018, 07:39:37 PM
So, I've been thinking about possible additions to SoaW: here are some of my ideas for what could turn up in future versions, do take or leave as you see fit :)

Extra Characters
There are so many options here! I'll just go through a few that I've thought quite a bit about.

Rogue
Melee 80, Magic 30, Archery 60, Health 80. Starts with a throwing knife, a rope, and +1 speed compared to most characters.
The rope (or it could also be a smoke bomb) is a special item with no attack that basically works the same as the teleport staff's mana ability. This means the rogue is very quick and can maneuver easily but also relatively fragile and doesn't have great starting stats. Possibly the character should have an extra boost to backstab damage, maybe instead of the +1 speed.

Paladin
Melee 80, Magic 50, Archery 50, 100 start health. Has some extra defensive abilities: possibly a sword that gives +1 shielding with each kill, plus regenerates 5hp per battle.

Dwarf
80/60/70, 120 health. Starts with a pickaxe weapon (axe-type, 16dmg, creates bombs with mana like the bomb bag as special). Lowish stats but tough and good at blowing things up, basically.

Extra Room Ideas

Extra Item Ideas


Misc Extras
Title: Re: Jubal's Ideas for SoaW
Post by: bigosaur on August 16, 2018, 02:50:23 PM
Rogue
Melee 80, Magic 30, Archery 60, Health 80. Starts with a throwing knife, a rope, and +1 speed compared to most characters.
The rope (or it could also be a smoke bomb) is a special item with no attack that basically works the same as the teleport staff's mana ability. This means the rogue is very quick and can maneuver easily but also relatively fragile and doesn't have great starting stats. Possibly the character should have an extra boost to backstab damage, maybe instead of the +1 speed.

I'm working on this with some minor twists. I gave him 100 archery because playing without a single skill at 100 makes him do very little damage. The Twisted Dagger is great for 80% melee at the start of the game: 16 dmg for throw/attack, but other melee weapons do low damage so the combat gets a little bit boring.

I scrapped the rope idea. I tried it out, but having the ability to teleport across the room at will is too OP. I also tried a variant where you need to build up rage to use it, but the throwing dagger is really slow to build up rage (basically, only when you use the backstab/knockdown attack, which is rare).

I gave him +1 speed and it feels great to play.

Now, the only thing I'm not sure how to do is to classify him as Melee or Archery because of the Hard Mode achievement. He uses melee at start, but has 100% archery skill, so I cannot decide. Any thoughts?

Title: Re: Jubal's Ideas for SoaW
Post by: Jubal on August 17, 2018, 10:09:05 AM
Hm, I think it could be either. It maybe depends mostly on what other characters you're planning, but I'd maybe lean towards archery, especially if you're planning another true melee character.

Quote
I also tried a variant where you need to build up rage to use it, but the throwing dagger is really slow to build up rage (basically, only when you use the backstab/knockdown attack, which is rare).
Are you sure this wouldn't work? I think I'd still find that a really nice special ability to have - it would make the rage building potions and the bull pet really helpful for the rogue, and you could use switching weapons in combat for a bit to build it up for a one-off when you needed to use it to teleport into hidden areas. Obviously you've been able to test it and I haven't, but I actually like the idea of it being a rage buildup ability and I think there are enough tactical options to make that useful. I think the trouble with only giving the rogue a speed boost to start with is that that's something any other character could happen to get on level 1, so they lack anything obviously special to the character type.
Title: Re: Jubal's Ideas for SoaW
Post by: bigosaur on August 17, 2018, 11:20:26 AM
Hm, I think it could be either. It maybe depends mostly on what other characters you're planning, but I'd maybe lean towards archery, especially if you're planning another true melee character.

Yes, more melee heroes are planned, but not sure if all will be added: Paladin, Dwarf, Female Knight.

Quote
I think the trouble with only giving the rogue a speed boost to start with is that that's something any other character could happen to get on level 1, so they lack anything obviously special to the character type.

Well, if you get another speed boost on level 1 you would be even faster. The difference between 7 and 8 speed is still significant.

But I do agree, there's needs to be something more that would make it special.

BTW, I have also given him the Scout Ring (see foes beyond doors) from the very start. But maybe having something more would be a good idea.
Title: Re: Jubal's Ideas for SoaW
Post by: Jubal on August 17, 2018, 10:24:50 PM
True - +1 speed definitely does make a difference, it would just be nice to have an ability that feels more "new" I guess.
Title: Re: Jubal's Ideas for SoaW
Post by: bigosaur on August 17, 2018, 10:35:02 PM
True - +1 speed definitely does make a difference, it would just be nice to have an ability that feels more "new" I guess.

I was thinking a lot about this today. There's an ability that works really well for a rogue sneaking and evading enemies, and it's tied to the rogue sword. Perhaps this hero should always start with that sword. Although this could be OP.

Maybe he can get that ability with all weapons - instead of having the weapon's regular rage attack, he would always do the sneak (turn into barrel) and get "surprise attack" bonus.

Edit: I could also tweak the knife throwing to slowly build up rage (just like arrows do).

P.S. I also though about lockpicking ability, but that would make the fox and keys useless. So, I gave him 5 keys to start with instead.
Title: Re: Jubal's Ideas for SoaW
Post by: Jubal on August 17, 2018, 10:49:10 PM
One way you could do lockpicking would be letting him use up keys (as well as/instead of bombs) to open regular non-key doors, which would allow the rogue to sneak around the level a lot more and escape bad combats better (but at a significant cost as you'd potentially be giving up on unlocking so many chests). I think always having the rogue sword would be OP on early levels. A bonus on throwing weapons like allowing throws to build up range would also be quite a cool feature though, I'd definitely be happy with that as an idea.
Title: Re: Jubal's Ideas for SoaW
Post by: bigosaur on August 17, 2018, 11:08:10 PM
One way you could do lockpicking would be letting him use up keys (as well as/instead of bombs) to open regular non-key doors, which would allow the rogue to sneak around the level a lot more and escape bad combats better (but at a significant cost as you'd potentially be giving up on unlocking so many chests). I think always having the rogue sword would be OP on early levels. A bonus on throwing weapons like allowing throws to build up range would also be quite a cool feature though, I'd definitely be happy with that as an idea.

Alright, I think it's shaping up pretty good. Here's my idea:

- stats: 80 melee, 100 ranged, 20 magic
- rage attack for all weapons gives the same effect as the Rogue Sword (drawback: cannot use Ice Hammer) or maybe the effect will only work for main weapon, and you can still use the regular weapon's rage attack when off-hand
- 60 HP (because rage effect is OP)
- no speed bonus (regular 6 speed like everyone) because rage effect is OP
- starting weapon: twisted knife (does a nice 16 dmg when thrown, 16+40 for backstab and 16+40+100 for sneak backstab: hard to pull off because of really short range)
- starts without keys or bombs. Instead has a unique "Lockpick Set" item that costs 4 mana to use and unlocks regular and locked doors (does not work with boss doors and blocked doors like the secret forest area and the One Coin Shop treasure room).
- I would also remove the Scout Ring effect I have given him previously, because with Lockpick you can scout rooms manually when needed :) and the actual ring and the related potion would still be useful

Unless you have something else to add/remove/tweak, I would program him like this.
Title: Re: Jubal's Ideas for SoaW
Post by: Jubal on August 17, 2018, 11:14:12 PM
OK, sure, sounds great - will need playtesting, but definitely sounds sufficiently clear/unique in playstyle and it should play for a nice, uhm, rogue like roguelike game! :)
Title: Re: Jubal's Ideas for SoaW
Post by: bigosaur on September 06, 2018, 06:54:16 PM
Catacomb: Vampire Hunter. Another adventurer found her way down and wants to prove herself by slaying a vampire. If you agree to help, she’ll follow you (only on this level, not through the portal) until either she dies or you kill a Vampire with her in the room, at which point she’ll give you a reward item and teleport out.

I started to work on this one today. I'm reusing the castle guard captain unit, but giving her a different color palette and the ice sword (I tried with the Retaliator and some other weapons, but this one looks best - and it also makes her quite deadly).

(http://bigosaur.com/vampire-hunter.png)

I have some problems writing her dialogue. Everything I try feels bland and stiff. I'm trying to evoke a feeling like she'd like to be a famous vampire hunter, but it's her first time down in the catacombs and she feels overwhelmed with the odds of doing it all by herself. Maybe something along the lines of "help me survive until I find a vampire to kill" or "could you take care of the other types of monsters", esp. since the player has to fight the bats as well if you attack a shop (killing the vampire boss would also count, but the player is more likely to just attack and kill the vampiress shop keeper). I have a general feeling of what it should look like, but cannot put it into words nicely.

Since it was your idea for this room, did you maybe have some idea what would she say to the player?

Help!  ;D
Title: Re: Jubal's Ideas for SoaW
Post by: Jubal on September 06, 2018, 07:41:47 PM
What's the maximum amount of text you want to have? I find it hard to visualise what a reasonable quantity is for this sort of thing.
Title: Re: Jubal's Ideas for SoaW
Post by: bigosaur on September 06, 2018, 08:22:44 PM
What's the maximum amount of text you want to have? I find it hard to visualise what a reasonable quantity is for this sort of thing.

There's no limit really. I can easily break it into multiple sections. For example, this is the text for the Skeleton Archer quest (Eye of Ramana)

Quote
Centuries ago, while I was still alive, I had a wizard friend, who cast a spell on me, protecting me from any form of mind control.

When the necromancer raised me from the dead, I resisted becoming his servant.

I’m free now, but I’m blind and thus lost in these catacombs forever...

There’s a magical artifact called The Eye of Ramana, which I can use to restore my sight.It’s in the tomb of the giant king, in the old part of the catacombs.

See that locked door? It leads into the tomb. I don't have a key and it's too dangerous for me to go inside by myself.

Lead me to The Eye and I will be forever grateful.

Oh, one more thing. If I happen to die along the way, you might want to defeat the necromancer and take his magic staff to raise me back from the dead.

This one is the longest in the game. Of course, the shorter it is, the better, but don't be afraid to make it longer if it means it would have more flavor.

Another example, Amanda (Pyromancer quest), says this:

Quote
My brother lives inside the castle. I need to get back to him, but I'm afraid of the goblins.

My brother is a powerful pyromancer. If you help me, I'm sure he'll return the favor.

Can I come with you?



I feel like 3 to 6 sentences is the best (long enough to add details, while still short enough not to "scare" the players).
Title: Re: Jubal's Ideas for SoaW
Post by: Jubal on September 06, 2018, 10:54:26 PM
Hm, OK, here are some options/ideas:

Vampire Slayer 1: Oathsworn
Quote
Hey!

Some years ago, my village was destroyed by a rampaging vampire lord.

Since then I've sworn revenge on them, so I came down here to hunt down some vampires.

There are many dangers down here, though. I need a fellow adventurer to help me complete my quest.

Help me kill a vampire and I will ensure you are rewarded.

Vampire Slayer 2: Professional
Quote
Hey!

I want to become a famous vampire hunter!

I heard there were undead down in these catacombs, and came here to hunt a vampire down.

But there are too many skeletons around, I need someone else to fight alongside.

Do you want to team up? Help me kill a vampire and I'll make it worth your while.

Vampire Slayer 3: Out of her depth/Funny
Quote
Hey!

I came down here because I wanted to become a mighty vampire slayer.

But there are a lot of skeletons... and I'm afraid of the dark...

...I need someone to help me survive down here. You'll do!

Let's go kill a vampire so I can achieve my dreams! I'll reward you if we kill one.
Title: Re: Jubal's Ideas for SoaW
Post by: bigosaur on September 07, 2018, 10:11:35 AM
Hm, OK, here are some options/ideas:

Awesome! I'll mixed up something from those (hope you don't mind). Here's what it looks like now:

Quote
I heard there were undead down in these catacombs, and came here to hunt a vampire down. I'm a famous vampire hunter, you know!

Well... to be honest... not really. I have yet to kill my first one...

You see, I'm not afraid of the Vampires. But those skeletons and mages are creeping me out. I need someone else to fight alongside...

Want to help me kill a vampire? I'll make it worth your while.

Any grammar errors I should fix? (I cannot tell if "I have yet to kill" or "I'm yet to kill" is the proper wording).
Title: Re: Jubal's Ideas for SoaW
Post by: Jubal on September 07, 2018, 12:35:24 PM
Looks great! Either is fine - I think "have yet to" is the slightly more common usage :)

My other thought is that visually, keeping all the gold in the colour scheme IMO makes her still look a bit too much like a castle guard captain. I wonder if silver armour might work better? I could play around with making a couple of colour variants as ideas if that'd help.


I've also been trying to game through even more character ideas in my head lately (trying to work out how one could do a bard, especially) and I've got a couple of new skinpacks ready that I need to upload. :)
Title: Re: Jubal's Ideas for SoaW
Post by: bigosaur on September 07, 2018, 02:03:10 PM
My other thought is that visually, keeping all the gold in the colour scheme IMO makes her still look a bit too much like a castle guard captain.

I was planning that to be an "elite" castle guard unit. So, she really is a well trained captain. She has 200 HP and 6 speed too. Beside this NPC, I might add some special challenge room where you fight a couple of those.

Quote
I wonder if silver armour might work better?

Actually, that was the first thing I tried. The problem is that the quest is in the catacombs where everything is grey and silver already, so it didn't look too good. Then I tried different colors. A green-ish variant also looks nice, but somehow doesn't feel like an elite warrior.

Quote
I've also been trying to game through even more character ideas in my head lately (trying to work out how one could do a bard, especially)

Mmmm, interesting.

BTW, I'm almost done with the set of changes I planned for the next release, so I will soon have a new version uploaded to the Steam beta branch.