MURDER ON THE ABYSSINIA: GAME THREAD

[Double A]

Who has the greatest deductive mind in the world then?

Clearly he was on to something for a trap to be sprung, where was he found? or had he moved to that position?

Askthepizzaguy. If you don't know him, that's a personal issue.

[Dimos]

I think Double A has something to hide, thus he is posting so strange posts...

like: ''It's awfuly quiet today'' and ''askthepizzaguy . If you don't know him, that's a personal issue''

he also said: ''Anyway, what's up with the complete and total lack of random lynching?''

and he voted for CN2 for being the first to propose peace -no lynch- . Possibly if he's scum then he wanted me and the Khan to eat each other like dogs so as he will gloriously murder some people during the night...

What do the rest of the people on-board think?

[CN2]

I don't like Phoenix's post earlier

Spoiler (click to show/hide)

My own take.

CG: The classic voyage persona. I get the feeling he may in fact have something to hide.

NightAngel: He's a smoker and therefore likely not the killer. The smoke would leave a distinctive smell on the man leading to easy identification.

Double A: Nervous. Perhaps something to hide. And insulting my RP'ing skillz. There's something strange about this one, watch him carefully guys.

PG: A mere innocent question I assure you. Trying to pass the time with my fellow passengers.

LadyHawk: A polite answer from an upstanding lass. I really doubt there is any ulterior motive behind this statement. I realise that this may in fact put suspicion on me as Dimos has already speculated that there is something of an understanding between us. For what it is worth, I give my word that this is not the case.

Mark: Trying to pass the time by breaking up the flawless RP'ing so far.

DD: A Titanic reference. As a matter of course, I suggest DD should be lynched first as bringing up that travesty on board a ship is just asking for bad luck.

Andalus: Undecided as this was simply a message to the captain.

It was far too convicting for that early in the game when no one has any information about anyone, except mafia trying to protect other mafia. Just saying, I could be wrong but it seems suspicious to me.

[Gen_Glory]

both ideas sound pretty sound but who really knows...

[CN2]

Hm, yeah they do. But the argument that Double A talks funny doesn't hold that much merit for me. As far as I can tell, that's just how he talks in any thread, what with only being here a short while we wouldn't know. Its not as if his comments are turned against anyone either, they just seem to be random :')

A mafia would want to turn everyone against a townie.

[Double A]

I think Double A has something to hide, thus he is posting so strange posts...

like: ''It's awfuly quiet today'' and ''askthepizzaguy . If you don't know him, that's a personal issue''

Please, enlighten me: In what way are those strange? Do you have something against jokes? Are you the joke police, mister joke hater person?

he also said: ''Anyway, what's up with the complete and total lack of random lynching?''

On the three sites I play mafia games on, it's scary if there are no random votes. Very, very scary. Even in serious games.

Especially in serious games.

and he voted for CN2 for being the first to propose peace -no lynch- . Possibly if he's scum then he wanted me and the Khan to eat each other like dogs so as he will gloriously murder some people during the night...

Get your facts straight. I voted him for being third on the bandwagon.

A lynch where there's even an 1 in 100 chance of killing a scum is better than a 0 in 10. Lynches are the town's most valuable tool in every game, even ones where there are vigs (which I really hope we have). However, due to the complete lack of vanilla townies in this game, we do need to be careful... but this doesn't mean we need to do a no lynch and nothing else (there was next to no discussion yesterday).

[Phoenixguard09]

I wish to pass off my post earlier as inexperience my good CN2. I have never gone through a harrowing experience before, only arranged them for others. 

[Visorslash]

I wish to pass off my post earlier as inexperience my good CN2. I have never gone through a harrowing experience before, only arranged them for others. 

 Vote: Phoenixguard009

[CN2]

Hm, I still don't trust you, and Double A is right, we do need to lynch someone especially after losing our 2nd most valuable player.

So, to add a bit more pressure (And to see if you can mount a convincing defence), Vote: Phoenixguard09

[Dimos]

Well, we might just search in the wrong direction, but I think that the tossed speculations might be of some importance.

If someone has knowledge superior to mine, just help us get that/ those scum/s undone. I'll think of who to vote twice. Double A and the inactives are my no1 consern ATM. We need a lynch, that's sure. We need to act quickly... Any proposals? ideas would be most welcome...

[Captain Carthage]

His nerves are showing!

Gut him!

Vote: Phoenixguard09

[Double A]

vote: Dimos for ignoring my accusation.

[Phoenixguard09]

I'd like to point out Visorslash that my comment was taken, entirely out of context.

(I was trying to say in character that I haven't played Mafia before, only run it for others.)

Further, CN2 good chap, while you give reasons for what could potentially be seen as a bandwagon vote, which I do not hold against you in any way, shape or form at all my good man, I would like to know what would constitute a convincing defence? I was not aware of doing something wrong.

Quite honestly, I am starting to perhaps reconsider my position on Double A. Although his willingness to  vote when we have basically nothing to go on is a little disoncerting.

Have a good day chaps and chapette,

[Son of the King]

That clarifies your strange comment a bit then. I am less suspicious of you now I know what you meant, rather than what it seemed like you meant.

I feel as though Double A is very eager for a lynching, which I guess isn't a bad thing considering we need to do something after losing Sherlock Holmes in the night . The only thing is, we need to be careful as we can't risk losing another powerful townie to a rushed lynching.

Having said that, I don't think he seems particularly suspicious. Certainly there are more suspicious people around and things happening, such as Dimos (simply because of what Double A himself said - not really huge suspicion, but certainly more than I see around Double A), or Nightangel's random bandwagoning.

[Son of the King]

Heh Just realised I repeated what Double A said completely about the lynching there... Can we edit our posts or not Jubal?