Exilian Mafia IV - The Village of the Damned Game Thread

[CN2]

It couldn't even be this Jubal "I've never yet seen a ruleset in which scum can fake trying to kill their own." As that would mean that half the players are scum...

At least we know there is a doctor about Now I am doubtful that Andalus is Scum, as he was the one that pointed out and first voted for scum before... And it would just be weird if you killed your team mate.

I think I am going to suspect DD, as he hasnt voted, and was very 'confused' when we were ganging up on his team mate, if he is scum of corse, it could of just been genuine confusion...

Also!!  :

[Andalus]

Hm, DD does seem the most suspect, not having voted nor argued against Dante.

[Andalus]

There is also the vague possibility it might be Jubal. He only voted for Dante at the last minute, but then equally if he had left it with three votes it would have gone to a no lynch, so probably not him.

[Gen_Glory]

wow  so because I cant make up my mind im automatically mafia?

[CN2]

In this situation, yup. Well possible scum anyway.

[DeepComet5581]

At least CN2 hasn't instantly blamed me this time.

Jubal, has it not occured to you that if CN2 IS scum, someone who isn't might have tried to kill him to get rid of the scum, and CN2s saviour may have been fellow scum.

I can't add to the argument at the moment cos i've got a f***ing cold, but they seem to make me decide between DD and Jubal. However, as no-one was directly seen and no-one was killed, it's impossible to tell unless someone role-claims.

[Gen_Glory]

well seeing as CN2 is quick to accuse and defend himself im suspecting him also I dislike being suspected

[CN2]

Think about it, it couldnt possibly be me, as that would mean there are 3 scum and a serial killer  (Plus why would scum kill their own team mate during the night...)

[Gen_Glory]

how do we know it was scum and not the one shot vigilante?

[CN2]

Hm, good point :/

[Andalus]

The way I see it, none of the four people who voted for Dante were forced to, and could easily have declined on the grounds of it being a shaky hunch. It would be a mistake to lynch your own teammate unless you really had to in order to prevent the whole mafia being uncovered. Therefore I am doubtful that anyone who did vote for Dante is scum.

There is one possible reason for scum voting for their own, and that is to create the false illusion that they are town, relying on the exact logic I just expressed. I think Ninja is in the clear, since he also brought up the matte of the howl. Voting for your own is one thing, pointing out extra evidence is another. I also think it unlikely that CN2 is scum, sinCe he was attacked in the night. It has been suggested that he could have been attacked by a vigilante, but note that it was a "huge shadow" that attacked him, and smashed down his doors. That smells of werewolf to me. Which leaves Jubal, who has not directly put himself in the clear, but nor is he especially suspect.

This leaves DD and Evil. It has to be said DD didn't put up a huge defense for Dante, although in a small game like this that in itself would be quite a dangerous move, as if the lynch still went ahead and Dante was proved to be scum, the eye of suspicion would fall on those who defended him. Perhaps the mafia realised this and decided that the way it was going Dante would just have to take one for the team. As such, DD is still suspect in my eyes. Evil we haven't heard a peep from, which could mean that he is playing a clever game of lurking in the shadows and hoping he isn't noticed. I'd quite like to hear what he has to say for himself, but for now, DD seems the most dangerous person to be left unbothered, and I'd like to force a roleclaim out of him.

Vote:Dripping D

[CN2]

I think that you have to post in the thread if you are performing night actions, so Evil must just not be playing.

Plus if DD is mafia then he is trying to get me lynched by making it seem like a vig attempted to kill me when it was him, clearing his name  But then if I did turn out to be townie all eyes would just go to him. Or BN..

Plus, if it was a one shot vig (That just happens to be a huge person with extreme strength) then the mafia wouldn't of performed a night action, which is stange...

[DeepComet5581]

... but until you know what the Mafia's night action was, you can't pin it on them.

It most likely was scum, though. Which exempts me and CN2, as he was the target and as Andalus pointed out, I gave extra evidence towards Dante and he turned out to be scum. I wouldn't have done that if I was scum as well.

[Gen_Glory]

for all we know the mafia may of just played cards lol

[DeepComet5581]

Exactly. That's where, as Andalus put it, Logic comes in. Did the Mafia actually attempt to kill Stormcloud, or plan to kill him, or someone else?

Sod it.

Vote: Jubal

He hasn't done or said anything to defend himself. Maybe he was hoping we'd forget about him. No-one else has any strong evidence against them but most of us can come up with good defences.