Would you rather?

[Jubal]

Parsley.

Parsley (the herb) or Parsley (from The Herbs)?

[The Seamstress]

Had to google The Herbs, afaik this never aired in Austria, but Parsley the Lion seems to be friendly, so...

Ice tea with lemon: green or black?

[Jubal]

Green.

(And yes he is in fact a Very Friendly Lion)

Slow worm or glow-worm?

[The Seamstress]

Glow-worm? I'm not sure I ever saw one.

Be only able to talk backwards or be unable to talk at all for seven days?

[Tusky]

Silent for seven days, probably a little less debilitating in the long run!

Treacle or syrup

[The Seamstress]

Syrup.

Sugar or honey?

[Jubal]

Honey, sugar is more versatile but I like honey.

Barometer or Hygrometer?

[The Seamstress]

I don't think I'd personally have use for either really, so random choice: hygrometer.

Caramel or cinnamon?