Would you rather?

[The Seamstress]

Wibble?

Have a longer autumn season or a longer spring season?

[Jubal]

Spring is greener.

Rivendell or Lorien?

[The Seamstress]

Rivendell, I think.

Write LotR fanfiction or Star Wars fanfiction?

[Jubal]

LotR fanfiction, certainly

Atlantis or El Dorado?

[The Seamstress]

Atlantis.

Have your capacity to memorise things increase 25% or have one life skill of your choice improve 50%?

[Jubal]

I think if I slept or healed or achieved stress reduction 50% better I might have a 25% memory boost from the lower anxiety and exhaustion anyway? So I'll do that.

Have a big fluffy blanket, or an even bigger, but marginally less fluffy, blanket?

[The Seamstress]

Big fluffy blanket is fine.

Game or seafood?

[Tusky]

I assume you mean game the meat? If so: seafood. Otherwise I'd rather have a world with games in it

Toffee or fudge?