Spoil a wish

[The Seamstress]

You can stop coughing more easily, but only through a magic ritual that requires a very secret secret ingredient that's so secret not even the most secret of the secret scriptures in the most secret secret libraries know what it is.

I wish I knew the secret ingredient and could magically heal your illness. 

[Tusky]

You learn the secret ingredient, but it requires 8 kilos of pure gold to craft.

I wish I knew an alchemist

[The Seamstress]

You know an alchemist! Or so you thought. Turns out they're just an ordinary ol' chemist.

I wish there was a meadow with sheep on it in front of my house instead of ugly concrete & parking lots.